Selective Sympathy

gaga-lady-gaga-20910432What a terrible shock it is to find you’re not who you thought you were. Even worse when you learn the discrepancy comes in an area of characteristics you held most dear. Recently I discovered I was not the sympathetic, all-compassionate soul I’d always prided myself on being. I learned in fact that I practice a kind of selective sympathy instead of universal understanding, and this discovery came just at the time I was privately chiding many of my friends for not having enough empathy for me after my husband died—oh, the stones one can throw naively from the imagined protection of a glass house.

Just as I’d released one of those mental missiles, I realized with a jolt that I hadn’t thought about what many of those friends might have been enduring themselves over the past year—or cared. Selective sympathy was the most I could muster in my self-absorbed state. The ugly fact bounced around in my head for a couple of weeks before I got the jolt that rebooted my self-esteem. It came unexpectedly from someone I didn’t even know: Lady Gaga. Yes, she of the outrageous platinum hair and power to shock with music and lyrics. In an Op Ed piece in the New York Times by David Brooks recently, he wrote of Gaga’s passion and bravery, her drive to live a full life without a template. He wrote a lot more and I urge anyone who missed that piece to follow the link above and read it—more than once. Obviously I did, and the essay reduced me to tears—many tears.

After I’d recovered enough to examine what happened to me when I was so affected by it, I realized I’d learned about something more important than selective sympathy. It was that we’re not only someone other than who we are in our dreams, but we’re who we are in relation to others.  It’s why we can feel so lost when we’re not with someone we’ve had a long relationship with. It’s not about how good that relationship was, for we can be just as displaced when a negative force we’re used to is removed as a positive one. I’m reminded of Elena Ferrante’s heroine in My Brilliant Friend whose life flows around her friend in negative and positive currents, but who never feels alive without her. But Lady Gaga’s story reminded me that when I reflect on and off of someone like her, and there are and have been others like her in my life, then the core beliefs I share with her and them about courage and passion and the importance of a unique life lived outside the social prototype become the truth of who I am. Of course that brought me to tears when I was finally reintroduced to the self I thought I’d lost.

Lately I’ve been dazed by the tasks springing up every day from the administration of my husband’s estate: the juggling of three homes on my own, the surprising investments no one knew about and the ancillary financial decisions smothering my oxygen. Lady Gaga reminded me that the person my husband wanted me to be was in fact not me. The personality traits I manifested when he was around were not in fact the ones I held most dear. I was most certainly who he wanted me to be. And in the interest of full disclosure I’d say some of that person must have pleased me too, or I wouldn’t have championed her for so long. I remember trying to reaffirm myself a decade before he died, but apparently I hadn’t accomplished the task when Lady Gaga’s life principle brought me to tears.

If you take the time to read that piece on her you’ll find it ends with a question: ‘Who would you be and what would you do if you weren’t afraid?’ Dumping my selective sympathy, I’m able to answer with a resounding, “Me!” It’s an important discovery, but just as vital is the realization that part of the ‘me’ we display day-to-day is a reflection of others. So perhaps it was reflective, rather than selective sympathy I was showing my negligent friends; I’d become more them than me. I like Gaga’s image better.

4 Responses to Selective Sympathy

  1. Wow, I’m so glad I read that just now. I know the power of that question – what would you do and who would be if you were not afraid – but I haven’t thought about it in a while. It’s especially important for artists, coupled with that idea of passion and whatever core desire moves you forward no matter what anyone else says. We’re lucky we get to play so many roles throughout our life and we’re never done. I’m currently playing the mom role which of course I feel passion for, but I can never be fully engaged without putting something else on hold. Clearly I’m not the only mom in history to feel this way! But your piece reminded me if we’re not self-reflective how can we be honest and happy and move forward? It was also very interesting that you touched on the roles we play in marriage, and how that can be partially pleasing but not completing. Being a natural connector, writer, teacher and mentor is how I think of your role, which maybe is different than you’ve seen yourself? You’ve nurtured an artistic community that also nurtures you and your talent. We see you!

    • Boy Rachel, are you ever right! You’re not the only Mom in history to think that way. And most certainly the novel I’m now writing is about just such a mom. I need to talk with you to vet some ideas!!
      And thank you for ‘seeing me’ as you put it. Often I don’t, which I know is true for many of us, and looking at myself reflected back from someone like you is the most flattering (in the truest way) image one could have. Thanks for being part of the community!!

  2. Sidney, This is another insightful and thought provoking piece like all of your recent writing. I think everyone can relate to being what others think they should be and it does take courage to stay true to yourself. I know I have to periodically redirect myself, but it is always worth it.

    • It takes a lot of courage to do that redirecting, and even more to just stop and have a look at yourself. Funny think is, some of us think we do this all the time but when somehting catastrophic happens to chage our lives completely, we find we hadn’t done as good a job as we thought. Starting early as you have is the best possible way to ward off that shock.
      thanks for commenting, Sheila.

We welcome you to the conversation! Please share your thoughts.